Malcom Glenn
Fellow, Future of Land and Housing
Record unemployment claims are beginning to illustrate the stark economic reality of the COVID-19 pandemic. We knew they were coming, but the numbers are still staggering鈥攁nd we鈥檙e nowhere near a sustainable respite from the damage.
Indeed, for some groups, the greatest pain is yet to come. The 2008 economic downturn is a sad, recent example of this: A projected that, by 2031, the decline in black household wealth resulting from the downturn would be almost 10 percentage points worse than the decline of white household wealth. That鈥檚 worth restating: While overall wealth will be down across all racial groups, the gap will be massively wider for black families 23 years after the start of the crisis.
That鈥檚 a tragedy in its own right, but the exacerbation certain to come from a global pandemic could be nothing short of catastrophic鈥攁ll the more so because of . We鈥檙e now about halfway into the 23-year period projected in the ACLU/SSRC report, and a similar 23-year projection from the current crisis puts our outlook into 2043. Assuming optimistically there鈥檚 not another unforeseen economic shock to go along with a housing crash and a pandemic, we鈥檙e talking about multiple generations of people who will be paying down this literal and figurative debt for years to come. And for black families, the inequities will be especially compounded.
Why are the ramifications of a massive recession so much more painful for black people? One of the biggest reasons is that black households are , which is in far more limited supply than housing for middle-class or upper-class families. As a result of lack of subsidies for limited housing assistance programs, as well as policies that favor homeowners over renters, black families have historically found their housing outcomes in a more precarious position than their white counterparts.
None of this is an accident. Beginning in the 1950s, black communities saw their neighborhoods literally , which overlapped with that made black home ownership challenging at best, and impossible at worst. The 2008 downturn was the result of ; the ultimate impact, unsurprisingly, was worse for those who were victimized by the financial institutions responsible. And while people the pros and cons of gentrification, its practical fallout has been .
That matters when you consider the home鈥檚 central role in familial prosperity. Families with wealth鈥攚hich are more likely to be white鈥攈ave of that wealth tied up in their homes, whereas black families make up a disproportionate amount of the more-than-35 percent of families without residential wealth. And homeowners boast a net worth , with white households overall.
Furthermore, a perilous job situation is to a perilous housing one. identifies neighborhoods where job losses have already occurred, allowing us to anticipate areas that may be ravaged by especially significant housing insecurity.
Because of the slow pace of testing, uncertainty around when we鈥檒l see potential treatment, and the resulting lack of clarity around when things will return to 鈥渘ormal,鈥 we don鈥檛 know exactly how bad the oncoming housing crisis will be. But whatever the effect, it鈥檒l almost certainly be more painful for black households.
There鈥檚 been a groundswell of support from parts of the public and private sectors to aid vulnerable communities during this time. Many of these efforts should be as localized as possible, either by earmarking funds to be utilized by local governments or, if feasible, directly delivering aid to communities that are suffering most. There鈥檚 precedent for this: Last month, California Gov. Gavin Newsom announced for undocumented immigrants. This crisis is as global as they come, but in order to protect vulnerable populations, it鈥檚 important to empower local leaders with the resources to intervene in their own communities.
It鈥檚 politically untenable鈥攏ot to mention inefficient and morally dubious鈥攖o disproportionately target aid to households solely by race. But we know a few things: Black households have taken the biggest long-term hit over the past 60 years and are likely to do so again this time; a family鈥檚 economic security is tied to its household security; and available data indicates an oncoming housing crisis. At this point, it鈥檚 no longer possible to save many black families from the devastation of the pandemic鈥攂ut by giving local leaders resources to help communities on the brink, we can mitigate some of what they鈥檒l have to endure in the generations to come.