Vann R. Newkirk II
麻豆果冻传媒 (ASU Future Security) Senior Fellow, 2025 & Fellow, Political Reform Program
麻豆果冻传媒 2020 (ASU Future Security) Senior Fellow Vann R. Newkirk II reflects on Hurricane Katrina for 鈥淭hree questions鈥 in The Fifth Draft, the Fellows Program鈥檚 monthly newsletter. Newkirk is a Peabody Award鈥搘inning senior editor at The Atlantic who covers race, democracy, and environmental justice.
What does 鈥淜atrina鈥檚 America鈥 mean to you as a journalist and as a citizen?
To me, after spending much of the past decade聽reporting on and studying聽race, disaster, environmental justice, and the state of democracy in America, the inescapable conclusion is that the basic logic of the country was laid bare by Katrina. The failure of the levees, the patterns of societal neglect, and the media narratives about survivors all reflected and exposed the fundamental issues with the country鈥檚 policy and culture. Now, in everything from the climate crisis to the erosion of civil rights, the things that Katrina revealed are there. That鈥檚 what 鈥淜atrina鈥檚 America鈥 means to me.
I鈥檓 a big proponent of finding beauty in grief. The more intense the grief the more intense the beauty.
How do you think the storm and its aftermath will continue to influence the next 20 years of policy and culture?
I think that Katrina helped spark a more frank and forward conversation around issues of race, class, and governance that had previously been more hidden, and in turn prompted some real movement by marginalized communities to seize the narrative. For me, the denouement of those two decades of change is the current anti-democratic backlash that we are currently witnessing. To me, the next 20 years of policy and culture are anybody鈥檚 guess, but my hope is that we don鈥檛 forget what we learned in 2005. And yet, we have an unprepared FEMA, we are destroying our safety nets for our most vulnerable people, and now鈥攂ecause of climate change, which our federal government won鈥檛 even acknowledge鈥攚e face down the prospect of an active hurricane season.
Your next project, a book entitled Children of the Flood, will explore the fates of some of the oldest Black communities in the United States in the path of climate catastrophes. What have been the most profound moments of both agony and ecstasy working on that project?
I鈥檓 a big proponent of finding beauty in grief. The more intense the grief the more intense the beauty. The first character of my book is Calvin Adkins, the town historian for Princeville, North Carolina, who was the first person to advocate for leveraging Princeville鈥檚 history as America鈥檚 first and oldest town in the nation incorporated by Black people. He believed the town鈥檚 history could save itself with historical preservation money, and eventually safeguard it against future flooding. But, six weeks after meeting him, Hurricane Matthew destroyed the town. From a craft perspective, things that I was banking on using鈥攕ources and artifacts in Princeville鈥攚ere gone. That was agony.
On the other hand, I鈥檝e been reporting, researching, and writing on this book since 2016. I now have sources calling me saying, 鈥淲e need the book out. You鈥檝e got to do this. It鈥檚 important to us.鈥 That鈥檚 ecstasy.
Subscribe here聽to receive next month鈥檚 issue of聽The Fifth Draft.